Mascara Answers

im reading too many reviews.
and i dont know what to get.
waterproof is supposedly clumpy but it holds a curl longer if you use the base.
but does the regular mascara do all that even with the base?
help me please

I own this mascara & I absolutely adore it! However, whenever my mom uses it (I introduced this mascara to her & got her hooked on it recently!) it looks thicker/darker on her eyelashes…what gives??
Is there a certain amount of coats or a way to apply it so as to achieve this effect? lol thanks

kinda stuck in between the two. which one is better?
and which one is easy to remove when removing mascara at the end of the day?